Subject: Alert: 300,000 climate deaths?: 'Report is worse than fiction, it is a lie!' -- Climate expert rejects claim of 300,000 climate deaths as 'methodological embarrassment' |
From: "Marc Morano-ClimateDepot.com" |
Date: Fri, 29 May 2009 12:48:19 -0400 |
To: "'Marc Morano-ClimateDepot.com'" |
Go
to www.ClimateDepot.com for latest.
Alert:
300,000 climate deaths?: 'Report is worse than fiction, it is a lie!' --
Climate expert rejects claim of 300,000 climate deaths as 'methodological
embarrassment' – May 29, 2009
Roger
Pielke Jr. Excerpt: The new report
issued by the Global Humanitarian Forum which makes the absurd claim that
315,000 deaths a year can be attributed to the effects of rising greenhouse gas
concentrations. Roger A. Pielke Jr., a political scientist at the University of
Colorado, Boulder, who studies disaster trends, said the forum’s report was “a
methodological embarrassment” because there was no way to distinguish deaths or
economic losses related to human-driven global warming amid the much larger
losses resulting from the growth in populations and economic development in
vulnerable regions. […]
It
is a methodological embarrassment and poster child for how to lie with
statistics. The report will harm the cause for action on both climate change
and disasters because it is so deeply flawed. […]
The
report is worse than fiction, it is a lie. These are strong words I know. […] Let me
first start by noting that the same group that did the analysis for the UN, the
Geo-Risks group in Munich Re, earlier this year published a peer-reviewed paper
arguing that the signal of human-caused climate change could not presently be
seen in the loss data on disasters.
Sampling
of current Climate Depot Headlines:
NY
Times: 'There are significant questions about robustness of numbers at heart of
' claim of 300,000 climate deaths
'Nearly
impossible to isolate contribution from human-induced climate change to
mortality from disasters'
Columnist
on claim of 300,000 deaths: 'For $40 billion, even I might be tempted to peddle
such despicable nonsense'
'There
are simply no words to describe the lunacy'
300,000
death claim is 'poster child for how to lie with statistics'
Renowned
Arctic Scientist Akasofu says 'cooler decades ahead' -- Rejects 'instant
climatology'
'World
temperatures have already stopped rising since 1998, which annoys the IPCC'
Journalist
claims Climate Depot is 'divorced from scientific reality' -- Notes 'steep spike
in page views' after Climate Depot Link
Morano:
'The evil leader of the climate denialist empire?'
'Climate
change is not just an environmental issue, it's also profoundly spiritual'
Video:
Aussie Geologist Plimer: 'Climate Change Religion is a load of hot air'
Report:
Burger King Calls Global Warming 'Baloney'
Former
UN Chief ramps up fear: Warming 'greatest emerging humanitarian challenge of
our time, causing suffering to hundreds of millions'
Scientist:
'How long a period of no warming can be tolerated before forecasts of total
warming by century's end have to be lowered?
'Global
warming scare will be as dead as scares about Y2 bug or acid rain'
Ratcheting
up Fear: Scientists Compare Climate Change to Thermonuclear Warfare
Hand
out: African officials ask for $1 Billion per-year in climate change funding
from rich nations
Claim:
Refugees Join List of Climate-Change Issues
Australian
scientists declare climate change 'a natural phenomenon'...warn of 'severe
COOLING'
Report:
Pelosi wants climate bill on House floor the last week in June
Does
'Hockey Stick' Creator Mann Admit 'Misrepresenting' Science?
'Use
of the more technically 'correct' term is actually less likely to convey the
key implications to a lay audience'
Michael
Mann: 'Potential future climate changes, are, technically speaking, projections
rather than predictions'
Claim:
Climate Depot has 'splashy and hugely misleading headline' about Michael Mann
Study
Finds Even Climate 'Alarmed' Americans Don't Want Cap-and-Trade
Gore's
groups kick into campaign mode to push climate legislation...paid staff grows
from 20 people to 120
Big
Oil Fights Back: Chevron CEO tells eco-activists their report 'deserves the
trash can'
Report:
'Inventory' of Pelosi's life: 437 times greater environmental impact than
average family
Climate
campaign targets kids age 6-14 to come up with 'solution'