/ ======================== / wed.dec.20021218 / ======================== / / 1010 / / 1058 / @ CityCouncil . / 1147 / about to start Cmtte on Health / 1240 / Christine Quinn : sorry time wrong / Judith McFarlan big hand about to vote - incre workers protected . science clear / also raises bar on worker safety - need more worker protection - ground 0 establish that have workers . small econ impact - Owner operated bar . staff quarter share ownership in CA bars / rental parties not exempt can only smoke if terminal / neg vent rooms for 3 yrs . exempts 7- 8 cigar bars but not transferable / Private clubs w no staff out sie Mnh quin I / clark - freedom of choice - exemptions - unequal -- abstain sears : aye / Steward - right not to smoke Van - health nes to life - cannot legislate human behavior - aye Oddo - one of 4 repub / process fair - aye / 5 - 0 - 1 abstention / / 1258 / / 1403 / City Council rollcall ? Christian invocation . / 1420 / Miller : choice between jobs & health / Quinn ran great process . Quinn : loophole - lie about second hand smoke . many many workers - migraines asthma / should not trade - clean up site vs owner operated / rooms where staff cannot go . / / 1427 / cell phone legislation - hugely popular in public & around globe 2 hearings - Mayor said bill unenforcable - how 'bout smoking bill . Littering , Illegal postering / Q of Life legislation - safe & clean streets Littering multiple caught in act : Postering : already administrative fine , MSN butterfly postering - 50 > $75 per poster . company name on poster presumptive / don't enforce on nbd kids & social groups . Anit Graffitti : sell tools 2nd offense $1000 & year in jail . / 1435 / Genero : 256A : .90 of air qual problems are indoor . on behalf of 10 - 12 yr olds / mother died Lung cancer , quit many yrs ago / So much cancer / also anti etching acid bill restricting sale & posession Sr citizen homeowner occupant - 20k - 30k .5 tax abatement . " change the way we approach public health " . / 1442 / NYC 1.9M$ midicare/aid / substantial concern on small busn . if fails by destroying small business - but will vote for . share pain if kills small busnesses / do believe w have impact on small business in immigrant communities / / Kopel : level playing field won't hurt any business . freedom from scourge / Saunders : Chr of econ development : abstaining . / soak the Rich & Corps / ban smoking / Clark : cigar bars - not met measure of - punitive not facilitative . many unintended consequences . Abstain / Davis : Father smoked - rights - aye / 257 cell phone - no / - Postering - must be gentle hand - may have unintended consequences . Rev Diaz : last vote - yes except on 146 / - going to Albany Delan : 257a cell - no - if in counci / 257a - no illusion that will be enforced / 256 / no brainer on health and on civil liberties / aye on health side graffitti easy / Galliger / 256a - cigar bars , mom & pop / went smoke free .3 , .5 bars 256a 257a no / 318a street naming aye Genaro aye / Gerson - nazi / Joone repe Golden pass / Jackson caviats but aye / jennings aye / Katz pass / Koeell lanza execpt 257 / liu 257 no / lopez excecpt 146 / 256 - political posters *** / 13M$ smoking ed taken compromise / abstain hypocritical - so vote no . / McMahon : cigar bars - no / fabric of community - irreprable damage / msocowitz nelson aye / perkins nazi / Provenzano - sponsor - antismoking advocate nazi / Quinn : aye / Reed : like Lopez , make choices - cannot support - *** Sanders : former smoker - desire - but money where mouth is , chr econ dev too fragile at this time / abstain - / Seabrook : 257 no / Sears : congrad mayor - 2 adiction excused / steward - patons & workers held hostage - vote yes vallonejr / listening to cell fone abstain 257a / / vann : all except 146 , worries abt small busn / aye webrin yassky all aye deplasio Golden : last fo 256 257 no / Katz : was smoker - solves the issues . concern for small busn . private property - cell phone , how bout flash lights / abstain on 257 / Monsurat : 146 no 267 no 256 no / oddo : Quinn did good job / visceral - mom & pop - health trumps . 9th draconian - prohibition - miller : echo - focus on impact - 42 7 2 / 44 7 / 28 +/ 42 7 2 />/ 51 / 1548 /